One of the most fun parts of wedding planning is undoubtedly setting up a registry. What’s more fun than going through online stores and setting up a list of all the cool stuff you want, and there actually being a chance you’ll get it!?
Unfortunately one of the best parts of planning is also one of the most heavily steeped in etiquette rules. A few I’ve run into:
- Don’t list your registry on your invitations
- Your mothers are the only ones who should be telling people where you’re registered
- Never mention the registry unless someone expressly asks your for the information
- Only register for essential items
- Register for A LOT of items varying in different price ranges
- Register at a minimum of three department stores (this one is especially outdated since registering is all about online these days)
- Never ask for cash, only stuff
Since a lot of couples are now living together before they get married, the need for stuff to start a new house is dwindling with weddings. That’s why companies have started up honeymoon registries. These websites let you list your destination, pick out things you’d like to do, and let guests “purchase” these items for you. Sounds like a rather progressive move right? Well, no actually.
Here’s why honeymoon and other cash registries are bullshit!
I explained how they work, but the ones I’ve poked around have the same set up. Those activities you list as wanting to do are all vague and show up no matter where you list as honeymooning. The guests aren’t actually paying for you to have lunch at a cute restaurant by the hotel. They’re just paying a ballpark sum of money that goes into a pot, with a note that says “so and so wants you to enjoy eating lunch some place nice!”
The way the website makes it’s money is it takes a cut of the gift, either paid when the guest makes their purchase or a lump sum percentage of your whole gift amount.
Now imagine asking for cash wasn’t a taboo.
You say “we’re going to New York for our honeymoon, and if you want to give us a gift we’d appreciate money to help us have a fun time!” and then your guests send you cash and checks for whatever they’re comfortable with giving, and you get to keep the entire amount.
These companies exist solely so you can ask for money, without breaking the etiquette no-no of asking for money. It’s 2012. There is no longer a reason for any of these rules to exist.
My advice: set up a wedding website (mywedding.com is easy and free), adding a note at the bottom of your invite to visit it for more information (Never only list the site, always include a call to action!) Have a section for information on your registry needs, and have a polite paragraph about your needs.
Is it for your honeymoon? Are you buying a home soon and need to save for a down payment? Have a story about your goal followed by a polite request for monetary gifts if one would like to give a gift.
And don’t forget the thank you note! If a relative is offended at your brashness for requesting money, but gives it anyway, a long hand-written thank you note describing how much their gift helped and how grateful you are will quell those flames. And I do mean hand written.